Fourteen people went out to look at the city lights. By the time the rescue boats got to them, a mother and her baby were already gone, and the man steering the wheel was in handcuffs.
You expect trouble when the weather turns bad. You do not expect it on a quiet Saturday night in New York Harbor, surrounded by tourist ferries and bright lights. But the water does not care about the plans you make for your weekend.
Just before 10:30 PM, a 911 call came in. A boat had flipped over near Liberty Island.
Adam Schwartz runs a local tour company called Sea the City. His crew was out on the water that night and saw the hull of the boat sitting upside down in the dark. They did not wait around for official permission. They just moved in and started pulling people up. According to local reports, his team managed to drag 11 people out of the cold harbor before the main sirens even got close.
Then the heavy machinery showed up.
It was a massive scene. Two Coast Guard boats, four fire department boats, and two police boats surrounded the area. A police helicopter circled above, shining bright spotlights down on the ripples to help the divers see.
When the divers finally went in, they found 27-year-old Sara Sanchez and her five-month-old daughter, Antonella. They were pulled from the water and rushed to a nearby hospital. But they did not make it.
Sara and baby Antonella were the wife and child of Andres Garcia. He was on that boat too. He survived the crash, but he lost his entire family in the water.
Andres works at a local spot called Il Punto Ristorante. When the news hit, his co-workers took to Instagram to try and make sense of the shock.
“What was meant to be a joyful family outing ended in unimaginable tragedy,” the restaurant wrote.
The police already know who was driving.
The man at the wheel was Manuel Hernandez, a 46-year-old from Manhattan. He was arrested on the spot. Prosecutors charged him with 13 counts of reckless endangerment. One count for every single life he put in danger that night.
SEE ALSO: More than 150 migrants rescued after Channel boat catches fire
The exact reason the boat went over is still a bit of a mystery. Officials have not released the full details yet, and timelines on the final investigation remain uncertain. Specific details about the condition of the boat itself are still being kept quiet.
Capt Doreen McCarthy from the Coast Guard stepped in to explain the operational reality of the night, pointing out the one good thing that happened in a very bad situation. She focused on the strangers who jumped in to help.
“We are extremely grateful for the heroic, swift actions of our partner agencies and Good Samaritan vessel who assisted in rescuing survivors from the water,” she said.
If that tour crew had not been out there, more people might have drowned in the dark.
Now, the harbor goes back to its normal routine. Ferries run on schedule, and tourists take pictures of the statue. But for the man sitting in a jail cell and the father who went out with his family and came back alone, the water will never look the same.
